Insurance

Hit a Deer in Massachusetts? How Your Auto Policy Handles It During Peak Season

By November 9, 2026No Comments

If you drive the back roads of MetroWest, the North Shore, or anywhere along Route 2 at dusk this month, you have probably already had a close call. November is the worst month of the year for hitting a deer, and the next few weeks are when most of these crashes happen.

State Farm released its annual animal collision data on September 15, 2026. Here is what it says, and how a deer strike actually works on a Massachusetts auto policy.

What the new numbers say

State Farm estimates there were more than 1.6 million animal collision insurance claims in the U.S. between July 1, 2025 and June 30, 2026. The company paid $1.9 billion in animal collision claim costs over that period. Nationally, the odds of a driver hitting an animal were 1 in 145.

Deer are by far the most commonly struck animal. State Farm ranks November, October, and December, in that order, as the months drivers are most likely to hit a large animal. In last year’s report, those three months made up 41% of all animal collision claims.

Massachusetts is not on the top 10 list, but our neighbor Maine is, at 1 in 85. The Insurance Institute for Highway Safety reports that deaths from animal collisions rose from 89 in 1975 to 210 in 2024.

Hitting a deer is a Comprehensive claim in Massachusetts

Most drivers assume that hitting anything with their car is a collision. Under the standard Massachusetts Automobile Insurance Policy (2024 Edition), it is not.

Part 9, Comprehensive, lists the types of losses the policy treats as “Comprehensive and not Collision losses,” and that list includes contact with a bird or animal. So damage from hitting a deer is handled under your Comprehensive coverage, not your Collision coverage.

Two things follow from that:

You need Comprehensive on the car. Comprehensive is optional in Massachusetts. If you dropped it on an older vehicle to save money, a deer strike may be entirely out of pocket.

Your Comprehensive deductible applies. The standard policy says that unless you selected a different amount, the deductible is $500. Many drivers chose a different deductible years ago and do not remember what it is. It is printed on your Coverage Selections Page.

If you swerve to miss the deer and hit a guardrail, a tree, or another car instead, that is a different story. That damage is generally handled as a Collision loss, with your Collision deductible, and fault rules come into play.

Will a deer claim raise my rates?

Massachusetts uses the Safe Driver Insurance Plan (SDIP) to adjust premiums for accidents and claims. Under the SDIP regulation, 211 CMR 134.00, a paid Comprehensive claim is reported to the Merit Rating Board, the same as other incidents.

The good news is that the regulation sets a high bar for surcharge points on Comprehensive claims. Points may not be assigned unless you have four or more Comprehensive claims totaling $2,000 or more, and claims for acts of God are excluded from that count. For most drivers, a single deer claim is unlikely to trigger a surcharge on its own. Carriers can also use their own rating plans, so how your premium responds depends on your carrier and your history.

What to do if you hit a deer

State Farm and the Insurance Information Institute recommend a few simple steps, and we add one Massachusetts-specific reminder about your policy:

  1. Get to a safe spot. Pull over if you can and turn on your hazard lights.

  2. Call the police if the animal is blocking traffic. Stay away from an injured deer. A frightened animal can kick hard.

  3. Document everything. Take photos of the road, the surroundings, and the damage to your car.

  4. Check the car before driving on. Look for leaking fluids, tire damage, loose parts, and broken lights.

  5. Report the claim promptly. Tell your agent or carrier it was an animal strike so it is set up under Comprehensive.

How to lower your odds

Slow down and stay alert from dusk to dawn, when deer are most active and hardest to see. Use your high beams when there is no oncoming traffic, since they pick up the reflection of animals’ eyes. Take extra care in marked crossing zones and where roads cut between woods and fields. If a deer steps out, brake firmly and stay in your lane.

One more tip from State Farm and the Insurance Information Institute: do not count on deer whistles, fences, or reflectors. They have not been proven to reduce collisions.

A quick policy check before the holidays

Holiday travel and early sunsets put a lot of Greater Boston drivers on dark roads at exactly the wrong time of day. It takes five minutes to confirm you have Comprehensive on every car you would want repaired, and that your deductible is a number you could actually write a check for tomorrow.

Send us your declarations page

Not sure whether you have Comprehensive on every vehicle, or what your deductibles are? Send us your current auto declarations page. We will review your coverage with you, explain how a deer claim would work on your policy, and show you your options before peak season is over.